C O N T E X T 1 1 6 : S E P T E M B E R 2 0 1 0 17 IHBC Annual School 2010 IHBC Annual School 2009 IHBC Annual School 2010 This example predated the publication of PPS5 – we should perhaps consider whether the new policy framework is a revolution, or merely a codification of existing best practice. Harlow’s example demonstrated the importance of understanding the significance of an asset.This understanding can help to inform the nature of the proposed interventions and to avoid conflict in the negotiation process. Harlow was keen to stress the importance of adopting a proportionate approach, to ensure that the significance of an asset is sustained. A requirement for information beyond this objective could stifle the investment necessary to maintain a heritage asset. The key message of the presentation was, at least for me, the practical demonstration of how to balance benefits. This included balancing that most elusive of all things, public benefit, against a loss of significance. It is perhaps not the most original aspect of the new PPS, but certainly the area where the conservation professional’s judgement is likely to be tested. In the case study, minor harm was caused through the loss of access to the exposed innards of the gutted ruin and minor physical interventions. But this was balanced against the benefits arising from securing a sustainable and appropriate new use for the structure, removing the threats to significance arising from redundancy and continuing decay. This was an exemplary and highly informative demonstration of how PPS5 should be applied in practice. It was a helpful lesson for all conservation professionals. I think some members would have been interested in understanding the application of some of the more complex and novel elements of the new PPS, such as the protection of non-designated heritage assets and assessing major harm to significance. But I am sure there will be many seminars on the new PPS over the coming months where such matters will be discussed in detail.Who knows, Harlow himself may be there to answer such questions. Marc Timlin Structural works to the Royal Albert Hall It is unusual for a structural engineer to address the summer school. As an engineer myself I was looking forward to this talk, not least because of my past involvement with the Albert Memorial and visits to the Royal Albert Hall during that time and as a concert-goer. Bob Stagg in the roof of the Albert Hall with Dave Chetwyn, Richard Spooner and Eddie Booth (Photo: Fiona Newton) The Royal Albert Hall from Prince Consort Road (Photo: RobertWalker)
RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy MjgyMjA=